Here we are finally with our second "stand alone" Star Wars movie. I feel it is only fair to preface this by saying that from the moment this movie was announced, I thought... WHY? First and most importantly, because nobody can or should replace Harrison Ford as Han Solo. Second, because I think it takes something away from the character if we know too much as far as specifics of his background. I don't NEED to know his back story, or why he is cynical. Like... I never watched ANH and wondered, gee, why so cynical, Han? Nope, I didn't wonder that any more than I wondered why Luke was so innocent or why Leia was so self assured. They just... are.
My fears only magnified as things progressed, and more new Star Wars movies kept coming out, because they only seem to know how to retroactively make things worse for all of our heroes, so my assumption was that this would be no different. Especially once I learned they were giving him a real love interest, rather than maybe a random girlfriend or two (or more), given how they have treated Han and Leia to this point, I only assumed that they would again somehow try to use this as a way to twist the knife in my back even more. So now that we know what I was thinking before, let's get to the review.
We begin on Corellia. Again it is so odd to have a Star Wars movie that begins without the infamous crawl, but instead there was an intro that just came across in the same font as the "A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away..." which they also showed, they explained how Corellia is all full of crime and how all these children are forced to steal and whatever. They seemed to like borrowing some things from other versions of Han's back story while choosing to change others. So then we meet Han, who steals a speeder and drives it back to I guess the lair where all of the other children who are forced into crime are. Oh and right away we get our first sighting of the infamous dice, which for something that I, as a lifelong Star Wars fan who had seen the movies dozens of times over the course of my entire life have only consciously noticed in ANH maybe twice, are suddenly now like the most important thing in the universe to Han for some reason. I guess Han is supposed to be pretty young still here but it's sort of weird because he looks like an adult, and we see a bunch of little kids bringing in whatever they stole.
Han comes back with something that is apparently worth a whole lot of credits so that he and his girlfriend Qi'ra can buy a ship and finally get away from Corellia. How do we know she is his girlfriend? Because he kisses her within like a minute of them being on screen together. Right away I felt like I was tossed into the middle of a story, which I guess can kind of work sometimes, but I just didn't feel like it worked well here. I have no idea how long these two have been together or what kind of relationship they have aside from the fact that apparently they kiss and have talked about leaving.
So after they kiss a second time, just to make sure the audience knows that these two are boyfriend and girlfriend, Han is brought in before Lady Proxima, who is basically a giant lizard lady who lives in a small pool of water and for some reason is in charge of this crime syndicate of enslaving runaway children to steal for her. So like I guess that makes it different from the EU, because it's not Garris Shrike, it's a girl this time. And a lizard. But other than that it seems basically the same, and Han is beaten a little while Qi'ra watches for some reason (probably, again, to show the audience that she cares about him and doesn't like seeing him beaten) and they manage to escape into their speeder and there is a chase that we don't really care about that much as they head for this transport to get out.
As they are evading Imperials among the people walking around, Han hands Qi'ra those dice... for some reason. We don't really know why, she just kind of smiles at him. They get separated though as Qi'ra gets taken and Han can't get to her and he basically loses it, although, again, at this point we really have absolutely no idea how long these two have known each other and I didn't really feel much for Han when she was taken away. Han is understandably nervous as he still fears being apprehended but fortunately he spots where he can go and join the Imperial Academy because he wants to be a pilot, but also, mostly, because he just doesn't want to be captured. This was a change from Han's old back story where it is a more conscious decision for him to join up rather than a spur of the moment decision, and I'm not a fan of this change, but whatever.
Of course the more annoying thing that happens here is that when Han is giving the guy his name he just says his first name and the guy is like, "Who are your people?" And Han just stares at him blankly and the guy is like, ok, Solo. So that's how he gets his last name, in the dumbest fashion ever even though nobody really ever questioned why his last name was Solo. Not to mention the fact that it doesn't make any sense that he would keep such a name given to him by an Imperial officer. But at this point their "logic" is so faulty you are a lot more willing to just roll your eyes and let this stuff go. Because seriously, I never wondered about where his last name came from.
We immediately cut to 3 years later and Han is in some sort of ground war that resembles World War II, which is sort of weird because given the technology of Star Wars, it just seems odd that any of this fighting would happen as ground combat, but whatever. But it is here that we meet Woody Harrelson's character Beckett and his girlfriend Val. I should tell you right away, if you were excited for another female character, and finally a woman of color, do not get too attached to Val. They are in Imperial armor as well but Han realizes pretty quickly that something is off and they stole the armor, and for reasons I definitely do not understand this makes him assume that they would be a good choice to help him get off this planet and go be a pilot like he wants to. Before that though Han has to mouth off a bit to his lead officer after he says they need to take out the hostiles, and Han reminds him that this is their planet and the Imperials in this case are the hostiles. I guess it took him THREE YEARS of being an Imp to notice or say anything? I don't quite follow.
Anyway, Han proposes his idea to Beckett, who doesn't like that idea and instead gets Han turned over for desertion and he gets taken away so he can be fed to "the beast." Here is another predictable moment where I immediately guessed who the beast was probably going to be. So Han gets dropped down into this caged in pit and is attached at the ankle to whatever this beast is. The beast wanders out of the shadows and.... of course it is Chewie! Yay! Except maybe not so much yay, because as was mentioned, Han is down there to feed him since he apparently hasn't eaten in a few days. I should also note, I have no idea if Chewie had any other purpose than to remain chained up and occasionally eat insubordinate soldiers. So now of course Han and Chewie are battling, Han is trying not to get eaten, and just before Chewie drowns Han in mud Han says something to Chewie in Shriiwook. Because how convenient that he can already speak it for some unknown reason!
So instead of being eaten, the two escape together. This is maybe the back story change that I disliked the most, and the one that comes closest to actually making me mad. In the old version, Han frees Chewie from slavery because he finds slavery appalling, and that defiance is what gets him kicked out of the Academy. It is also what leads to Chewie's life debt to him and why he stays with him all those years. In this version he doesn't so much save him as use him as a means to not die himself and then kind of gets stuck with him, and then Chewie stays with him for pretty much no reason at all. It should also be noted that there is a moment in the trailer where Chewie affectionately leans in and presses his forehead to that of another Wookiee, which I think made most of us assume that it was maybe Chewie's wife or something. But turns out, nope, just a random Wookiee later on.
So Han and Chewie are still attached and Han tries to flag down the departing ship of Beckett and his crew because I guess they're friends now because they interacted for 10 seconds before Beckett turned Han in as a traitor. But John Favreau's wise-cracking alien pilot character Rio Durant seems to think it would be good to have some extra muscle, so they go back and pick them up. Which then leads us to the scene that we never thought we'd get to see, Han Solo naked in the shower. And then Chewie joins him. Ok, I admit, that was legitimately funny. And there were for sure a few moments in this movie I genuinely laughed, but it doesn't make up for the rest of it.
Eventually our new crew here has some quiet time and there is some talk about how Han is doing what he is doing for a girl, so he is still thinking about Qi'ra. But more importantly for now, they all need to go deal with this train heist thing for some reason that escapes me. So this leads us to a long action sequence of our new little band of criminals trying to steal stuff from a train. This scene is ok I guess, but I should note that at this point in the movie I was incredibly bored and had no idea what really we were supposed to want to see happen. This was an action sequence for the sake of having an action sequence. And like, cool train I guess, but ultimately, whatever.
The heist does not go exactly as planned because they are attacked by Enfys Nest and his crew. We know Enfys is a bad guy because his helmet/face mask are "evil" looking. I'm so glad that Star Wars makes everything so black and white for us in this regard. Other than that, I have no idea who these guys are or if it was ever explained. So this whole plan kind of goes to crap and Rio is trying to bring the ship in to help them but he gets shot and isn't doing so well. But hey, good news that Han finally gets to show off his pilot skills as he hops in to take over just before Rio dies. So, I hope you weren't too attached to Rio either. Val had been waiting to blow up a section of the bridge to take out the rest of the train and the ship was then going to take away the one train car that had the hyperfuel on it (apparently we're supposed to care a lot about hyperfuel - at least I think that was what was on it, honestly I'm not positive on that). Because the plan is going so badly she finally blows the bridge when she is still on it and she dies. I honestly am not sure what the successful version of this plan was supposed to look like.
Beckett and Chewie manage to get back on the ship with Han and they have their haul but Nest's team gets some cables on it and they try to steal it too. Beckett tells Han not to let go as they are heading toward a mountain, but Han finally lets it go before they crash, Nest's crew can't support the weight of the car themselves on their speeder-bike-like vehicles and they lose the cargo which then causes an incredible explosion that basically destroys the mountain. Beckett is none too thrilled with Han about that and is already in a pretty bad place because his girlfriend is dead. Conversations are had though and Han and Chewie decide to continue to stick with Beckett.
I should note that at this point in the movie, every scene so far just seems exceptionally dark. And I don't mean tone-wise, I mean like you want someone to turn up the lights because it's just plain hard to see.
So now they have to go and confess that they did not complete their little mission and must visit Dryden Vos who is the leader of the Crimson Dawn crime syndicate. You will remember that name because I swear they say the words Crimson Dawn at least a dozen times throughout the movie. And I swear it sounds really familiar but the only thing I can think of that it might be reminding me of is that part in Die Hard when Hans Gruber is asking for random people to be released to meet his random demands and he mentions Asian Dawn. For real, I was like, we get it, you're Crimson Dawn. But that's not the most important thing here. No, the most important thing is what an unbelievable coincidence it is that when they go to meet him, who do they see at this party but Qi'ra! Seriously, the galaxy is practically infinite, and Han just happened to totally randomly connect with this dude who just happens to work for a guy who has been with Qi'ra for a while.
There whole reuniting here is just odd. Han is of course thrilled to see her since basically everything he has done recently has been so that he could go back to Corellia and get her. While she seems to be more like, "Oh, cool, hi." Uh... ok. Then they just start totally casually talking like nothing is weird at all about this. So then we go and meet Dryden Vos who really would rather just kill them for not completing their mission but instead decides to let them attempt to redeem themselves, but definitely for sure if they don't complete THIS mission he will totally kill them. Also during this it seems apparent that Dryden and Qi'ra are "together." But it's definitely a creepy sort of thing and you can tell that Qi'ra isn't really happy about it, but she has a marking on her wrist that matches the symbol on a ring that Vos wears. But also for some strange reason Vos sends Qi'ra with them.
So, they need to go to... Kessel! And in order to do so, they need a fast ship. Good news, because Qi'ra knows someone. If you guessed that someone is Lando, you're right. So this is one of the few bright spots of this whole thing. Donald Glover makes an excellent young Lando, and from the time he was announced I was like... ok, so maybe not EVERYTHING about this movie will be terrible. I think he manages to just slip into the Lando persona without just doing an awkward impersonation of Billy Dee Williams. He has the confidence and the charisma and I would probably sign up for more Lando movies. Han joins in on Lando's sabacc (which they say differently than I've been reading it in my head for over 20 years, but I'll get over it) although I was a little confused because I seem to recall that there was sort of a digital element to it that would change the cards in your hand, and now it just seems like regular cards. We get to the big hand at the end and are betting ships and, well, Han loses. And he loses a fake ship he never actually had. Oops.
Anyway, instead of taking the ship for themselves they just sign Lando onto their crew and promise him a percentage of the take. Well, that was an easy problem to fix as well. Then we meet Lando's droid L3-37, who is an outspoken droid, and a female voiced one, who wants equal rights for all droids. She added a fair bit of humor to this that certainly was enjoyable at times, I do admit. So then we finally go and see the Millennium Falcon for the first time. This was also the first time I actually kind of noticed the score since it hearkens back to the original Star Wars score. This happened maybe two more times and other than that, the score was remarkably underwhelming. Han, you can tell, is immediately in love. At some point on this trip over Han and Qi'ra share a moment in Lando's cape closet. She is trying some on, and they both decide that maybe Lando has too many capes. They kiss a couple of times, again to remind us that they should totally be together in spite of their staggering lack of chemistry. Han wants to know what has been happening with her all this time, and she says she doesn't want to tell him because he would never look at her the same way again. We never do find out what exactly she has been up to that whole time.
So, now to get to Kessel and steal these um... again I think hyperfuel, but it was expensive and explosive which is the most important thing to know. On the way there of course we learn about how to navigate it and whatever. We also get a brief moment between Qi'ra and L3-37 where the droid says how she can tell that Han is in love with her, and Qi'ra says how it won't work. And then L3 says she gets it, because she can tell that Lando totally loves her but she knows that won't work either. If any of you have seen the thing going around about how Lando wants to have sex with a droid, I assume this is where that comes from, but to me it just feels like a funny joke.
Oh and also on this trip Han and Lando share a brief exchange where Han mentions that his father used to build YT-1300s and Lando asks if he was close with his dad and Han says, "Not really." So, now we are adding more confusion because it seems maybe Han did have a family, and he remembers them, and something happened. So did he have a last name or what? Did he run away or was he taken or did his parents die? We have absolutely no idea.
So we arrive on Kessel and the plan is that Qi'ra pretends that Han and Chewie are new slaves to give to them and then they all try and take over the place. Little Easter egg here where Beckett is wearing the bounty hunter disguise that Lando wears in ROTJ. So I guess that outfit just lives in the Falcon forever for all those occasions you need to dress up as a bounty hunter. Qi'ra hands Han back those dice during this scene, which we are still not given any sort of context for. During this whole thing we have a few random moments. Han and Chewie escape and Han is now in disguise, Chewie gets distracted when he sees Wookiee slaves and decides he needs to go and free them. Han doesn't go with him, so again they are really kind of changing how Han feels about slavery in general here. He isn't sure if Chewie will be coming back. L3 also frees a droid from its restraining bolt, mostly to get it away from the control panel she wants to use and she kind of off-handedly tells it to go free everyone else, so mass chaos erupts as the droids basically revolt, and then they free the human slaves as well and everything is kind of a mess now.
Chewie manages to free the Wookiees and eventually they do make it back to the ship but not before Lando takes a blaster to the arm and L3 gets mortally wounded, so Lando is very sad about that and carries her upper half with him as Chewie carries him back to the ship and they escape. But hey, good news you guys, since Lando is wounded, that means Han gets to show off his piloting skills! It should be noted that at this point we don't really know if Han has spent much time at all actually piloting. But hey, it is the new thing in Star Wars that people are just innately talented at things and don't really have to practice or learn new skills. So these explosive canisters they have stolen are highly volatile and must be processed within a very short time of being taken, so they need to go to a nearby planet but of course time is very short. So short, in fact, that it is basically impossible for them to do it, because as Lando says here, "Nobody has ever made the Kessel run in less than 20 parsecs." So, you guys, Han makes his famed less than 12 parsecs Kessel run the very first time he flies the Falcon. Because we are probably two thirds of the way through this movie and we must explain every little thing so it has to happen now or never.
They make it out and to this planet to process this stuff so it doesn't explode. Han and Lando share a brief exchange where Lando says, "I hate you," and Han says, "I know." So, that was the only reference to that, and that I can deal with. Although because of the timing and stuff I don't think anyone picks up on the REAL joke there, because everyone just laughs immediately after Lando says he hates Han. But then Enfys Nest shows up again. How or why? No idea. Han seems to think that they can fool them into thinking that they have a bunch of backup on the Falcon, but just as Han finishes telling them about this, Lando and the Falcon take off and leave them behind.
Well, then we learn that Enfys is... a young girl. This is I guess supposed to be a pretty big reveal, because even as of now there is no actor listed on IMDB for that character. I don't really know why she is a young girl. But anyway, turns out she is basically trying to help the Rebellion and they all decide that they should work together and they devise a plan. Beckett decides that he doesn't really want a part of this anymore and he leaves, so Han and Qi'ra and Chewie go back to see Dryden Vos so that he can make good on that whole not killing them thing, and even pay them. They tell him that Beckett is dead. Vos though realizes that what they have brought him back is fake (we as an audience are not aware that their plan was to bring back a fake, we don't know until he points it out) and he is, well, REALLY mad. Han thinks that Qi'ra betrayed them, but Vos points out that it wasn't her, and he is especially unhappy that she was in on this because it means she was on Han's side. Nope, we find out Beckett had turned them in and he reminds him that he already told him never to trust anyone. I should also point out again that there is a moment here with Vos and Qi'ra that is just weird and creepy and you don't really know what is going on between them. Just the way he puts his hand on her neck in what in another context might be considered affectionate but considering the look on Qi'ra's face and how uncomfortable she is, it definitely does not come off as affectionate.
Of course massive fighting ensues and Qi'ra winds up killing Vos. Han and Qi'ra are so happy now and she says that he can go ahead and she will just stay behind and grab these expensive jewels that are conveniently strewn about the room so they can use those to pay for their new ship and leave. So Han leaves but instead of grabbing the jewels, Qi'ra contacts someone through holocall (is that what we call this?) and we don't really know who it is at first, we just know that he is evil because of the deep voice and the hood he is wearing. Except then he takes off the hood and we see it is... Darth Maul! And I swear people by this point are probably so far removed that they don't even remember that he was sliced in half at the end of TPM. It should also be noted that when discussing the movie afterward, my brother was also sort of confused on the timeline and thought that maybe this lined up with the prequels before he died, except for that to be true, Han would be older than Leia's father. So, no to that.
More importantly at this point, I need to talk about how I have no idea what is going on with Qi'ra. It's all incredibly unclear. She is clearly very uncomfortable with Vos, even though it is pointed out that she is "committed" to him because of the marking on her wrist/ ring thing. But I have absolutely no idea if this was a situation she was forced into, or if this was like, her long-term plan to just go along with him as a way to secure her place with Maul later on after she betrayed Vos. Really, it is incredibly confusing. She also seems to have very little personality other than the fact that she is the girl in the movie, which is also the only reason really that Han probably wants to be with her so badly.
Han has one more final confrontation with Beckett where he "shoots first" and kills him, because he for sure would've killed him if he had the chance. Han assumes at this point that he will now go back to Qi'ra but then he sees her take off on her ship and leave him as she looks at him sadly. Again, I'm very unclear on her feelings about him here. Mostly she doesn't seem that into him. But she's still kind of sad to be leaving. But again I don't know if this was her grand scheme or if she feels like she has to do this or what?
I should also note that at this point in the movie I was like... ok but what is the END? And when? First I believe there was one last conversation with Enfys where she asks if Han wants to come with her to join the Rebellion because they need leaders and heroes and Han is like, no thanks. And she says maybe someday he'll change his mind and he says, "Don't hold your breath." FINALLY though we go find Lando again and Han wants to play sabacc with him again. I forgot to mention earlier that Han noticed that Lando had cheated at their last game, but he never said anything about it. Well, this time he knows how he cheated and when he greets him he is able to steal Lando's cheat card and Han is the one who cheats and wins the Falcon and he and Chewie fly off into the sunset, with those stupid dice hanging up in the cockpit. Is this the "after what you pulled" that Lando is talking about in ESB? Maybe? Oh and Han is heading for Tatooine to start working for Jabba because Beckett had mentioned him earlier. And FINALLY the movie is over.
Phew, ok. So, my overall impression was that I was pretty bored much of the time. And there was sort of an underlying plot in there, but not really. It's like they had a checklist of things they wanted/needed to cram into this movie and contrived a plot to stick underneath it while making sure to hit the main points. The strange thing is, this movie "explained" a lot of things we never thought really needed explaining, (the name Solo, or the origin of the dice, which again hardly anyone knew existed until they decided to make them central to Han Solo's character to the point where I'm sure in any future releases of ESB and ROTJ they will digitally insert them because they were only actually in ANH) while at the same time not at all explaining the things that they said this movie would explain. Like... Han doesn't really change in this movie. To me, it doesn't in the slightest "explain" his cynicism in ANH. It's not like he was all that trusting early on in this movie. Qi'ra also at one point says how she is the only one who knows who he really is, which is "the good guy." Of course Han protests to this, but again, this is how ANH Han would've reacted as well.
It doesn't at all explain why Han might have dealt with Luke and Leia how he did when he met them. I don't know, it doesn't really give us much explanation at all for Han's personality. He already has it here when we meet him. The good news is that the thing I was most worried about, further undermining Han and Leia, is definitely not something I needed to be worried about. Their relationship here was forced and without chemistry. She doesn't even seem that into him. Yes, he seems to be doing everything he is doing basically FOR her, but I'm not sure how much that matters if she doesn't really reciprocate. I mean, I don't look at the guy and really think he's Han, but if I did, at some point I kind of wanted to hug him and be like, "It's ok, someday you're going to meet Leia and she is going to treat you right." They don't say I love you. There is for sure no implied sex in the movie, and they are ambiguously young when we meet them, and living in like, caves with a bunch of other kids so for all we know at this point, they never had sex in the first place and Han is still a virgin. We really have no idea.
I was really worried about the acting going in. Alden does... fine, I guess. I mean certainly there are times where it's like you can SEE him acting, and he doesn't seem to embody the character at all the way others do. Which is interesting to me because in the other movies so far, no matter how I felt with them, I have always felt like the casting was well done. But again this was an impossible task to start with, hard to embody a character that is totally someone else's persona already. Emilia Clarke, well, I don't know if it is her acting or just the lack of chemistry, but meh, I just didn't care about her that much. I did appreciate getting to see some different female outfits in the GFFA but that is about it there. Paul Bettany is kind of over the top as the villain here, and this is apparently going to be the summer of seeing Paul Bettany die a lot. Avengers: Infinity War spoiler: He dies TWICE in that. And once here. That is a lot of dying for one actor. But if you want creepy, well, he certainly gives you that.
Woody Harrelson, well, I have to say that I feel like he is the same in everything and no different here. Not very good. I don't get him. He felt out of place. Donald Glover as Lando, as I said, excellent.
I'm mostly just relieved that the things I thought would make me mad definitely did not. I spent a lot of time wondering when it was going to be over because they did not do a good job of making me care, and half the movie I couldn't even see because it was so dark. I definitely don't feel like this "romance" was portrayed in a way that made it seem like, more important than what Han has with Leia later. Although still, I don't know about the dice thing. Yes, they pass the dice back and forth. But I really don't know if we are supposed to be left thinking that to Han the dice represent Qi'ra or if they are just a random lucky charm that he happened to give her at one point and she gave back, or what.
This movie also reminded me how annoying it is that even though they have been given an infinite universe to play with, and infinite timelines, they choose to keep focusing on this very small part of it and fill in every little unnecessary gap for these people. This TYPE of movie probably could've been fun and interesting if they gave it its own story rather than just trying to stuff in all these references to things in Han's past. It's fun to get to see some new planets and some new costumes and some different environments. But it's all just lost in the fact that I just don't care that much what is going on.
Ok, so, mostly boring. A lot of eye rolling things like the last name thing. A lot of confusing and unexplained things like Qi'ra's motivation. And the only kind of maddening thing to me was taking away Han's pretty noble moment of freeing Chewie from slavery because he thinks it's wrong, and not just because he doesn't want the Wookiee to eat him. Alden didn't make me mad or anything, but I didn't feel like he was Han Solo. There were some genuinely funny moments, and you kind of want to just watch Lando do his thing a lot longer. Mostly I'm relieved that it didn't upset me or anger me and now we're left with a movie that would be difficult to sit through again just due to boredom, although admittedly I'd probably watch this again before I'd watch TLJ again.
I think that is finally it, but let me know what you think or if you have any questions about it!
My review:
ReplyDeleteOverall, I'd give it a 7/10. Not terrible like TPM or TLJ but not amazing like RO or ESB or anything. The beginning and middle part until Lando shows up really drags. Once Lando shows up the film really kicks into high gear and the rest of it is a fun ride. It's nothing groundbreaking or epic like the OT but if you just go in expecting an entertaining movie for 2 hours you'll probably be fine.
- Some of the action sequences were boring and overly long like the train heist. The Kessel Run was a ton of fun though.
- Lots of this movie was so dark I could barely see what was going on.
- A couple really good "This is Star Wars!" moments like when Chewie gets into the co-pilot seat for the first time and the Star Wars score kicks in.
- They really hit you over the head of how important the dice are with like 10 close ups of them. It felt kind of contrived like they're really trying to bridge Solo to TLJ. But we never really get any idea of why they are important to Han, for example are they the only thing he has of his family? But I didn't get the impression like a lot of reviews said they're a symbol of his love for Qi'ra. You can see they're important to him before he gives them to her.
- Donald Glover is the highlight of this movie for me. You can totally see him becoming Billy Dee Williams later on and he channels his charm effortlessly. I love getting to know more about him, like his cape closet and how close he is to his mom.
- Alden was fine as Han. Yes, he doesn't look anything like Harrison Ford, so you have to suspend that to believe the movie. He got his mannerisms down though, and he really channelled Harrison in a lot of the scenes.
- I may be in the minority, but I found L3 annoying and over the top with the droid rights things, and the implication L3 and Lando were in a romantic relationship was super weird. In Last Shot which takes place right before Solo, there is no insinuation of that of any kind and they have a great banter back and forth.
- Vos was a great creepy villain, but was underused. He never even leaves his lair.
- Val was criminally underused. She shows up as a super bad ass female character but then she dies like 10 minutes later. They make her death to be this big noble sacrifice but it's not like she died like Jyn doing something that would save billions of lives, she dies so that her boyfriend can try to get some fuel.
Delete- That said I did like to see that we saw an interracial couple even if it was briefly.
- I much prefer the old EU backstory of Han rescuing Chewie because he couldn't stomach the slavery of the Empire and getting kicked out of the Imperial Academy because of it. In this one they just make it an accident that he happens to rescue Chewie at the same time he rescues himself.
- I felt Han lacked the motivation and ambition we saw in the old EU where he signs up to the Imperial Academy to make something of himself. In here, his only motivation throughout the movie is to rescue Qi'ra, and while that's honourable and in character, we don't really get a feel for what his hopes and dreams in life are beyond being with her.
- I did like how much this movie felt like a love story between Han and Chewie. That's the core of the movie, the romance is just a subplot.
- Qi'ra, I didn't think Emilia Clarke was as bad as some of the reviews made her out to be, I thought she did fine with what she had. I did feel like her character was really underwritten and she's only seen over the eyes of the men she's involved with, which is a classic problem with male writing of female characters. We are never given any insight into what she thinks or her motivations. Maybe the novelization will expand on this.
- I really did not like that they made her a victim of sex trafficking and then implied concubine of Vos' and took away her agency. It would have made her a much stronger character to have her decide like the female character in Claudia Gray's Lost Stars to join the crime syndicate as a way to get off Corellia and show agency. But instead they made her a victim of her circumstances and beholden to the men surrounding her. I also don't like the idea of giving a female character a history of sexual violence to make her complex. I wish they had just made her an ambitious social climber who chose the life and understood the sacrifices that came with it. I didn't see femme fatale, she was basically just a victim who was trying to survive.
I was disappointed Emilia Clarke was cast over the 5 WOC who were in final auditios and according to concept art Qi’ra was supposed to be a WOC, and it really is getting tired that all 5 SW heroines are white brunettes and the last three white British brunettes. That said, it would not have been great either if the first WOC lead was a sex slave, so it's kind of a lose/lose.
Delete- As a Han/Leia fan, I was worried this film might try to undermine Han/Leia by portraying Qi'ra as this perfect relationship that only ended through her death, so I was glad that didn't happen, and that she didn't get fridged for manpain. I appreciated that unlike Bria, Qi'ra was nothing like Leia in background, morals, principles, personality, anything. Han/Leia fans shouldn't worry, the relationship totally came off to me like a youthful love that Han idealized and hung onto for years, while Qi'ra moved on, and Han's arc is realizing that that is in the past and moving on. It's kind of a parallel to Rey who's always trying to get back to Jakku in how Han keeps talking about how he needs to go back to Corellia and both of them at the end of the movie move on from their past.
- Their relationship could be seen as some as an epic star crossed lovers who couldn't be together because of circumstances and I definitely felt like they were pandering to the YA crowd who loved Reylo with it, but I thought the film really hammered home that they are ultimately incompatible in their beliefs and lifestyles, and that Qi'ra realizes this while Han is hung up on the past. They never even really get back together, Qi'ra tells him all along that it won't happen because she can never leave the crime syndicate because they will hunt her down and kill her, and she won't endanger Han's life. The only time Han thinks that they're going to get back together Qi'ra is clearly acting the whole time, and I don't think this was done maliciously, I think she knew the only way she could get Han to leave was for him to believe she was following him.
- In the end what distinguishes Qi'ra from Luke and Leia is that ultimately she is a pragmatist. She will do whatever it takes to stay alive, even if it means hurting and killing other people. Luke and Leia, and Han (even though he doesn't want to admit it) couldn't do that because they're idealists, they would risk their lives or sacrifice themselves to do the right thing. The whole scene with Enfys Nest foreshadows Han's relationship with Luke and Leia later on. Han is very taken with Enfys' idealism , the way he later will be to Luke and Leia. This isn't even to say Qi'ra is a bad person, had she not done what she had she'd have likely been killed a long time ago, and Luke and Leia were both given moral compasses in their adoptive parents while she never was. Qi'ra sees things more clearly than Han does who is blinded by his idealistic memory of their relationship on Corellia - she knows that deep down Han is a good guy and that he couldn't be with her with what she's done. That's why in that scene where she's talking with Enfys Nest she knows that he'll do the right thing. Leia and Luke on the other hand will risk their lives to infiltrate a criminal organization to rescue Han.
- They really bring home that Crimson Dawn is an evil organization, not just a standard "we have to do underground crime because the Empire is an oppressive dictatorship" in that scene with Enfys Nest, and Qi'ra has clearly done very bad things for the organization when you see her guilt when she hides her Crimson Dawn tattoo.
I feel like she wasn't a full on villain in this movie, but at the end when she takes over for Vos and reports to Maul, you know she's going to go on to do pretty evil things. I feel like she didn't chose this lifestyle and it's not what she would have chosen with her life, but this is her life now so she might as well make the best of it by getting ahead in the organization, and even though she has feelings for Han, she won't let that influence what she's decided to do in life. She's good at working the system from within while Han will fight against the system even if he risks his life to do it. I know they say she can't leave the organization or she'll be hunted down and killed so it's totally understandable why she stays (and again she's had a horrible life so you totally understand her choices), but again this distinguishes her from Luke, Leia and Han who all put themselves on the Empire's Most Wanted list when they blow up the Death Star.
Delete- Kasdan kept saying how we will see how Han goes from being a naive good guy to cynical selfish guy we meet in ANH but I didn't see that at all. He's basically a good guy throughout the entire book, the movie ends with him giving all the fuel to the Rebels. I definitely don't see Solo Han as saying "Better her than me" in ANH. I guess they are setting it up for sequels where he gets screwed over a bunch more.
- This movie is actually pretty good fodder for those (*cough*JJ) who think that Han is a wanderer who couldn't settle down. Han in this movie desperately wants nothing more than to be with one person and settled down, but she rejects him. I'm glad we didn't see womanizer Han like Indiana Jones/James Bond. And if he was celibate 3 years waiting for Qi'ra, then, I'm sure he was celibate between Bloodline and TFA when he was separated from Leia. He's a loyal monogamist and this movie shows that.
- The elevator/Vos' lair scene was a completely rip off of the TLJ elevator/throne room scene, down to Qi'ra and Han riding the elevator up, not knowing where her motivations are, it looking like she was going to kill Han but she ends up killing Vos, and then Han assumes she's going to run away with him but she ends up taking over instead.
Enfys nest was awesome and the best thing about this movie.
Thanks for taking the time to review this, Zyra (and for watching it in the first place). I am in no rush to see it, but now I don't feel panicky in case the family wants to go.
ReplyDeleteI hate the tack they've taken in filling in every little detail (e.g. his surname) and messing with his backstory (especially taking away his heroism in rescuing Chewie and opposing slavery). But whatever. It's all just big-budget fanfic at this point, and not very good fic at that.
You're welcome! It really is big budget fanfic and that's it. And it is becoming a lot easier to view it as such. I don't think you'll hate it. I think you'll be a little bored, you'll laugh a few times, you'll enjoy Lando and Chewie, and probably at least not be angry. Maybe some eye rolling, but that will be the worst of it.
Deletehttps://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/box-office-solo-a-star-wars-story-struggles-hit-100m-us-crashes-overseas-1114854
ReplyDeleteSo I guess no sequels??
I can only HOPE that the powers-that-be will (finally!) seek answers from the fandom and discover belatedly what they should have discovered a couple of years ago: (a) THERE IS ONLY ONE HAN SOLO and (b) NO ONE WANTED THIS MOVIE in the first place and (c) THEY NEED TO STOP MESSING WITH THE OT CHARACTERS and MOVE THE **** ON!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteI really love the fact that the articles keep going on about "franchise fatigue" and hint at a divided fanbase (which is way bigger than they think) and seemingly ignore the elephant in the room (or should we say crafty old tiger)?
ReplyDeleteNO ONE wants to see a Han Solo movie a) without Harrison Ford and b) when you just killed him in one movie and then screamed about "killing the past" in the next one! Especially when you trashed Luke along the way.
But whatever, Disney. I'm just sitting here, sipping delicious tea.
I think it’s unfair for people to say that no one wanted this film. I wanted it. Since 19&3. I love Han Solo so much. I have shipped H/L for that long as well. They are the best and their fanfic writers and fans are what attracts me to this type of site. All that being said, I have been enjoying every bit of media for this film since it all stared leaking out. I’ve seen the movie twice and will see it again. While not as strong as H/L, I ship Han and Qi’Ra. I hope for sequels. Alden is fantastic as Han Solo and I really hope all this negativity doesn’t mean the end of his take on this amazing character.
ReplyDeleteEeessh....I'm glad this movie bombed. No one wanted to see a movie about young Han Solo with non Harrison Ford playing him. I don't know why anyone thought we'd be interested in Han's backstory, did anyone really care about how he came to be a selfish smuggler in ANH? I know I didn't.
ReplyDeleteWhy was so much of this film SO DARK? I could barely see half of it. Makes me miss the gorgeous cinematography of Empire Strikes Back.
Donald Glover was a highlight. Enfys Nest was cool. Val was great until she sacrificed herself. The guy playing Han did all right, but still looks nothing like Harrison Ford. I saw they changed Han's height in the VD to be 5' 8 - guess they're going with Alden's height now? So now Han is shorter than Luke?
Woody Harrelson seems to play the same character in every movie. He barely looked like he was trying here.
I thought Han rescued Chewie from slavery, not the lame plot they came up with. So now Chewie eats people?
I don't feel like Han and Qi'ra threatened Han/Leia later on. He loved her obviously and she loved him, but they clearly could never be together and I think Han finally got that at the end of the movie that he had to stop living in the past. I did feel like they went a little far in making them these epic Romeo + Juliet star crossed lovers but I see Qi'ra as a formative romance, not the love of his life by any means, but someone who taught him about how harsh life really is under the Empire and crime syndicate. He was still naive and optimistic that they could have a life together while Qi'ra understood that that fantasy could never be a reality, that if she left with him it'd be signing a death warrant for the two of them and that option was never on the table. Although, their love story would have been more compelling if they had any chemistry, their lack of chemistry rivalled Dany/Jon in GOT.
My big problem with the film was how the female characters were handled. L3 was treated like a joke most of the time (plus if droids are slaves now does that make Luke and Leia slave owners? The whole inclusion was weird and unnecessary), Val was barely used and Beckett seemed to forget about her ten minutes later, and Qi'ra spent the whole film martyring herself to serve Han from the beginning to the end. I saw an article that says "She begins the movie telling Han to run while she remains trapped and suffers, she ends the film telling Han to run while she remained trapped and suffers". Han got to escape that life both times, she had to stay and suffer.
DeleteThen Han wanting to have sex with her in Lando's closet when she had being implied to have gone through a lot of rapey stuff in her past...eeeyyaahh, I'm going to just chalk that up to Han's naivety that he didn't get the kind of things she had gone through.
I'm over female characters who have no arc beyond how they relate to a man, you take away Han and Vos, and Qi'ra has nothing. I'm also over sexily dressed female characters whose entire purpose is to serve the arc of the male characters.
Qi'ra could have been a much better character if she had gotten control of her life at any point during the movie, but she just goes from serving one man to another at the end of the movie, constantly protecting Han and then risks her life to cover for Han by lying about what happened to Vos to Maul which allows Han to safely get away without being worried about Maul's enforcers finding him and killing him. Her entire arc revolved around serving the men in her life, at no point does she doing anything SHE wants to do. Which is a real disappointment when the actress who plays her gets to play such a bad ass character in her TV show.
Han Solo is also now 3 years older than he used to be. He's 22 in the Solo movie which is 10 years before Star Wars so he's now 32 rather than 29 there.
DeleteOf course they've changed Artoo's height too - he's now 10 cm taller. I can't tell that's he's taller because they don't let him do anything anymore.
Isn't Han 5'8" in the new visual dictionary too? How the hell tall will Luke and Leia be now - or is that waiting on whatever Disney kids they cast?
DeleteApparently the original version of Han meeting Chewie, Chewie would rescue Han, therefore no Life Debt. The next time someone tells me about how much Kasdan knows about SW? I'm going to whack 'em upside the head.
MauLer's Unbridled Rage on Solo is fantastic. NSFW!
https://youtu.be/_bQbYmLAZ_k
I don't know if this is true or not because I didn't read it, but is it true that the Aftermath book talks a lot about Chewie's life debt to Han? So like, if Han doesn't free him from slavery, where does that life debt come from now?
DeleteAlso, don't get me started on Val. I am still totally unclear on what the successful version of that plan would've looked like. Was it seriously worth blowing herself up just so they could steal some fuel?!?!? Like noble sacrifices are great and all, but they need to actually make sense. And exactly, then she is forgotten one scene later.
I can't even muster up the energy to be annoyed that they decided to shrink Han. Sure, the same guy was Han for 4 movies, but let's change all his stats to fit the guy who played him for one movie. Does he also have blue eyes now too? The age change makes no sense either. They can fit it into the timeline however they want! Why is he suddenly older?!?! Wait, probably so they would have time to do more movies with this kid when he's in his 30s. Sorry, please, just stop.
Thanks for reviewing. Since you said it wasn't as awful a retcon as I was expecting, I saw it today.
ReplyDeleteI actually enjoyed it (viewing it through 'civilian' eyes).
Lando was awesome. L3 was also great, but now all of Han's talking to the Falcon in the OT seems creepy. I preferred it when we thought it was Han's skill as a pilot that did the Kessel Run in 12 parsecs, not the brain of Lando's dead love interest. :(
One correction: Han didn't cheat to win the Falcon. He took Lando's cheat card, but he won legit.
I thought he pulled that card and pointed it out to Lando but he also USED it for his hand. I could very well be wrong though.
DeleteThe general consensus actually seems to be that a lot of people are enjoying it. Which is only funny to me since this movie of all of them is doing so badly. I'm sure I would've liked it better if they hadn't tried to make it Han, although even then I think they could've done a much better job of making me care more about these characters. They killed 2 of them so quick!
Han showed Lando the cheat card he took off of him, but Han won on the hand on his own. :)
DeleteYeah, I was surprised I enjoyed the movie as much as I did. Still haven't seen TLJ, and not planning to see #9. But I liked Alden as young Han.
There seems to be a lot of different interpretations on whether Qi'ra's decision at the end was her saving and protecting Han for selfless reasons or her choosing power over love but Ron Howard finally clarified:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.slashfilm.com/future-solo-sequels-ron-howard/
The Qi’ra Question
Qi’ra’s actions at the end of the film are purposefully ambiguous, but Howard has his own reading. When Qi’ra chooses to stay with Crimson Dawn and become Maul’s second-in-command rather than running away with Han, Howard sees it not as a moment of betrayal but of charity.”In my mind, she knew she couldn’t run off with Han. It would be his death and hers,” he said, adding:
“She set him up to go, assuring him that she’d follow, but knowing she couldn’t really. She had to clean this situation up as best as she could. I think she hoped she could report in and then disappear, but [Maul] trapped her. He said, ‘Come to Dathomir and we’re going to be working closely together’, and you realise, ‘Oh my god, she’s traded one oppressive boss in for an even scarier dude’. In a way it fuels her ambition and puts her in a position of heightened power, perhaps. Or heightened danger. I thought it was kind of courageous for her.”